| SALIX 
      KEY FOR SPECIES WITH GLABROUS OVARIES IN SASKATCHEWAN | 
   
    | * For a more accurate 
      and in depth Salix key, the reader is referred to the interactive 
      key created by Dr. G. Argus. This key is available through the Alaska Natural 
      Heritage Program at the University of Alaska. | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 1 Bracts of catkins white, yellow, 
      or golden brown | 2 | 
   
    | 1 Bracts of catkins brown to reddish 
      or black | 12 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 2 Capsules sessile or nearly so, stalk 
      less than 1 mm | 3 | 
   
    | 2 Capsules definitely stalked, stalk 
      more than 1 mm | 8 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 3 Twigs golden, yellow, orange or 
      yellowish-green (leaves green, dull) | 4 | 
   
    | 3 Twigs greyish to yellowish-brown 
      (leaves yellowish-green, semi-glossy) | 6 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 4 Female catkins 1.5 – 8 cm 
      long; dense ticket-forming shrubs; twigs light yellow to orange; capsules 
      4 – 8 mm long (leaves linear, sides parallel) | S. exigua ssp. interior | 
   
    | 4 Female catkins 3 – 6 cm long; 
      shrub or tree; twigs golden yellow to orange to greenish; capsule 3.5 – 
      5 mm long (leaves lance-shaped to oval) | 5 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 5 Large tree; twigs golden yellow 
      to orange | S. alba | 
   
    | 5 Shrub 2 – 6 m tall; twigs 
      yellowish-green | S. pentandra | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 6 Twigs shiny (leaves white-waxy below) | S. serissima | 
   
    | 6 Twigs dull (leaves pale beneath) | 7 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 7 Commonly less than 3 m tall, female 
      catkins to 10 cm, capsules to 7 mm long, on stalks to 2 mm long | S. lucida ssp. lasiandra | 
   
    | 7 To about 5 m tall, female catkins 
      to 5 cm long, capsules < 7 mm long, on stalks ca. 1 mm long | S. lucida ssp. lucida | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 8 Female catkins 3 – 8 cm long; 
      twigs drooping or arching | S. amygdaloides | 
   
    | 8 Female catkins 1 – 4 cm long; 
      twigs erect or ascending | 9 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 9 Twigs shiny | S. serissima | 
   
    | 9 Twigs dull | 10 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 10 Slender shrub, 40 – 100 cm 
      tall; bracts persistent; sphagnum bogs and swamps (leaves green above, white-waxy 
      below; stipules absent) | S. pedicillaris | 
   
    | 10 Shrub or small tree to 4 m tall; 
      bracts falling off early; swamps, shores and wet meadows (leaves yellowish-green 
      above, may be white or bluish waxy below; stipules present) | 11 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 11 Commonly less than 3 m tall, female 
      catkins to 10 cm, capsules to 7 mm long, on stalks to 2 mm long | S. lucida ssp. lasiandra | 
   
    | 11 To about 5 m tall, female catkins 
      to 5 cm long, capsules < 7 mm long, on stalks ca. 1 mm long | S. lucida ssp. lucida | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 12 Low, decumbent or trailing shrubs, 
      < 1 m tall | S. myrtilloides | 
   
    | 12 Shrubs 1 – 10 m tall | 13 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 13 Twigs closely gray-hairy; shrub 
      to 7 m tall | S. eriocephala var. famelica | 
   
    | 13 Twigs hairless; generally to 4 
      m tall | 14 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 14 Buds with a balsamic fragrance | S. pyrifolia | 
   
    | 14 Buds not fragrant | 15 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 15 Female catkins sessile or subsessile 
      (leaves white or bluish waxy below) | 16 | 
   
    | 15 Female catkins on leafy stalks 
      (leaves not white or bluish waxy below) | S. pseudomyrsinites | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 16 Female catkins 1 – 3 cm long 
      (leaves short tapered) | S. turnorii | 
   
    | 16 Female catkins 3 – 7 cm long 
      (leaves acute to obtuse) | S. pseudomonticola | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | SALIX 
      KEY FOR SPECIES WITH PUBESCENT OVARIES IN SASKATCHEWAN | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 1 Shrubs trailing or very small (< 
      10 cm tall above ground) | 2 | 
   
    | 1 Shrubs erect, taller than 10 cm | 3 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 2 Female catkin scales black; capsules 
      6 – 9 mm long; stems trailing | S. arctophila | 
   
    | 2 Female catkin scales reddish to 
      yellowish; capsules 4 – 5 mm long; stems mostly buried | S. reticulata ssp. reticulata | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 3 New twigs permanently white felty-woolly; 
      Lake Athabasca only (leaves nearly white, oval to lance-shaped) | S. silicola | 
   
    | 3 New twigs hairless or otherwise 
      hairy; distribution various (leaves generally green, at least above) | 4 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 4 Branches gray-brown, exfoliating; 
      shrubs 30 – 200 cm tall; Lake Athabasca | S. athabascensis | 
   
    | 4 Branches various colours, not exfoliating; 
      shrubs 30 cm to 4 m tall | 5 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 5 Female catkin bracts dark brown 
      to black | 6 | 
   
    | 5 Female catkin bracts yellow to brown | 13 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 6 Bark dark brown; catkins nearly 
      round; shrub 2 – 3 m tall; Lake Athabasca | S. tyrellii | 
   
    | 6 Bark reddish, greyish, dark brown 
      to yellowish-brown; catkins generally longer than wide; distribution various | 7 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 7 Female catkins sessile or nearly 
      so | 8 | 
   
    | 7 Female catkins on leafy stalks | 10 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 8 Female catkin scales black | 9 | 
   
    | 8 Female catkin scales dark brown | S. arbusculoides | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 9 Bark brown; capsules 4 – 6 
      mm long; shrubs 3 – 5 m tall; boreal forest | S. pellita | 
   
    | 9 Bark greyish; capsules 5 – 
      10 mm long; shrubs 1 – 5 m tall; widespread in Saskatchewan, prairies, 
      aspen woods and mixed woods | S. discolor | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 10 Branches dark brown to yellow-brown | S. scouleri | 
   
    | 10 Branches dark brown to reddish-brown | 11 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 11 Capsules purplish-tinged; northwest 
      Saskatchewan | S. x brachypurpurea | 
   
    | 11 Capsules not purplish; distribution 
      various | 12 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 12 Female catkins 1 – 3 cm long 
      (leaves 5 – 10 cm long, margins glandular-saw-toothed on later leaves) | S. petiolaris | 
   
    | 12 Female catkins 2 – 6 cm long 
      (leaves 3 – 5 cm long, margins slightly rolled, sub-entire to remotely 
      toothed) | S. planifolia | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 13 Capsules 8 – 10 mm long, 
      long-hairy to gray-woolly (leaves green below, with red and white matted 
      hairs that are soon lost) | S. macalliana | 
   
    | 13 Capsules < 8 mm long, hairs 
      various (leaves various) | 14 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 14 Shrubs < 1.5 m tall | 15 | 
   
    | 14 Shrubs or small trees to 4 m tall | 17 | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 15 Capsules white-woolly; styles red | S. candida | 
   
    | 15 Capsules woolly to long-hairy; 
      styles green |  | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 16 Female catkins 1 – 2 long; 
      bark grey to reddish; branches long-hairy (leaves narrowly elliptic to egg-shaped, 
      greyish-white hairs on both sides; see leaf key for varieties) | S. brachycarpa | 
   
    | 16 Female catkins 2 – 5 cm long; 
      bark dull grey; branches gray woolly (leaves egg-shaped to elliptic, dark 
      green, hairless to short-hairy above, with a waxy bloom below) | S. glauca ssp. glabrescens | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | 17 Capsules 5 – 8 mm; female 
      catkins 2 – 5 cm long; bark reddish (leaves 2 – 6 cm long) | S. bebbiana | 
   
    | 17 Capsules 3 – 6 mm long; female 
      catkins 3.5 – 11 cm long; bark dark reddish-brown to blackish, waxy 
      bloom often prominent (leaves 4.5 – 11 cm long) | S. drummondiana | 
   
    |  |  | 
   
    | SALIX 
      KEY BY LEAVES IN SASKATCHEWAN |  | 
   
    |  |  | 
  
    | 1 Leaves green below | 2 | 
  
    | 1 Leaves with a white or bluish waxy 
      bloom below | 15 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 2 Leaves linear, the sides parallel | S. exigua ssp. interior | 
  
    | 2 Leaves narrowly elliptic to broadly 
      oval or egg-shaped | 3 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 3 Leaves densely hairy beneath | 4 | 
  
    | 3 Leaves hairless or only sparsely 
      hairy beneath | 7 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 4 Length to width ratio of leaves 
      2:1 or 3:1; trees or tall shrubs 2 – 7 m tall; leaves densely long-hairy 
      to silky-hairy below; margin entire to rolled | S. scouleriana | 
  
    | 4 Length to width ratio of leaves 
      6:1; shrubs to 5 m tall; leaves silky-hairy or woolly below; margin entire 
      to shallowly toothed, may be rolled | 5 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 5 Shrubs less than 3 m tall; leaves 
      narrowly elliptic to egg-shaped, silky or woolly below, hairy above | S. pellita | 
  
    | 5 Shrubs 3 – 5 m tall; leaves 
      narrowly lance-shaped, densely silky or woolly below, hairless above | 6 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 6 Leaves narrowly elliptic, margin 
      entire to shallowly toothed; upper surface dark green, sometimes turning 
      dark brown, thinly woolly; shrubs 30 – 150 cm (catkins sessile) | S. candida | 
  
    | 6 Leaves narrowly elliptic to distantly 
      glandular or round-toothed-glandular, upper surface dark green, sparsely 
      long-hairy to hairless; shrubs 1 – 3 | S. drummondiana | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 7 Leaf margins entire; leaves and 
      stems persistently white felty; Lake Athabasca | S. silicola | 
  
    | 7 Leaf margins entire to toothed; 
      leaves and stems various but not persistently white felty; distribution 
      various | 8 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 8 Leaf stalks glandular at leaf base; 
      leaves oval to elliptic, glossy above, margins glandular-saw-toothed | 9 | 
  
    | 8 Leaf stalks not glandular; leaves 
      elliptic to egg-shaped, not glossy above, margins glandular-saw-toothed 
      to round-toothed | 10 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 9 Leaf base round, green above, apex 
      abruptly tapered | S. lucida ssp. caudata | 
  
    | 9 Leaf base obtuse, very dark green 
      above, apex tapered | S. pentandra | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 10 Low shrubs (< 1 m tall), usually 
      creeping or trailing | S. myrtillifolia | 
  
    | 10 Shrubs usually over 2 m tall, erect | 11 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 11 Leaves leathery, matted with white 
      and reddish hairs that soon fall off | S. macalliana | 
  
    | 11 Leaves thin, hairs various | 12 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 12 Leaves lance-shaped 3 – 8 
      cm long, margin saw-toothed | S. eriocephala var. famelica | 
  
    | 12 Leaves elliptic to egg-shaped, 
      2 – 9 cm long, margin saw-toothed to glandular or round-toothed | 13 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 13 Leaves 5 – 9 cm long; branchlets 
      highly glossy | S. serissima | 
  
    | 13 Leaves 2 – 5 cm long; branchlets 
      sparsely hairy or dull | 14 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 14 Young leaves reddish, sparsely 
      long-hairy; northern Saskatchewan | S. pseudomyrsinites  | 
  
    | 14 Young leaves green, sparsely covered 
      in reddish hairs; Lake Athabasca | S. tyrellii | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 15 Dwarf shrubs, trailing or erect, 
      < 10 cm tall | 16 | 
  
    | 15 Shrubs or trees, > 30 cm tall 
      to 10 m | 17 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 16 Shrub trailing along the ground; 
      upper leaf surface smooth | S. arctophila | 
  
    | 16 Shrub erect, very small, mostly 
      below ground; upper leaf surface impressed veiny | S. reticulata ssp. reticulata | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 17 Leaf margins entire or indistinctly 
      toothed, may be rolled | 18 | 
  
    | 17 Leaf margins distinctly toothed | 29 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 18 Mature leaves densely hairy below | 19 | 
  
    | 18 Mature leaves hairless to short-hairy 
      or sparsely hairy | 22 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 19 Upper leaf surface glossy and dark 
      green; stem exfoliating | S. glauca ssp. glabrescens | 
  
    | 19 Upper leaf surface dull or hairy; 
      stem not exfoliating | 20 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 20 Leaf stalk green; shrubs or trees 
      to 5 m tall; branching in pairs; leaves not appearing in fan-shaped arrangements | S. bebbiana | 
  
    | 20 Leaf stalk reddish to yellowish; 
      shrubs 0.3 – 1.5 m tall; branching not in pairs; leaves appearing 
      in a fan-shaped arrangement because of short internodes | 21 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 21 From sand dunes of Lake Athabasca | S. brachycarpa var. psammophilus | 
  
    | 21 Distributed in northern Canada 
      in meadows, thickets and fens | S. brachycarpa var. brachycarpa | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 22 Shrubs 30 – 100 cm tall; 
      branches gray-brown, exfoliating; Lake Athabasca | S. athabascensis | 
  
    | 22 Shrubs usually over 1 m tall (except 
      S. glauca var. glabrescens); branches reddish to gray; distribution various | 23 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 23 Leaves 5 – 10 cm long | 24 | 
  
    | 23 Leaves less than 6 cm long | 25 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 24 Leaf length to width ratio 3:1 | S. discolor | 
  
    | 24 Leaf length to width ratio 6:1 | S. petiolaris | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 25 Tall shrubs or trees, 2 – 
      10 m tall | S. discolor | 
  
    | 25 Low shrubs, 20 – 400 cm tall | 26 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 26 Leaves glossy and dark green above | S. glauca ssp. glabrescens | 
  
    | 26 Leaves dull above or glossy with 
      sunken veins | 27 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 27 Leaves wrinkly below | S. bebbiana | 
  
    | 27 Leaves veiny or not, but not wrinkly 
      below |  | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 28 Leaves elliptic to egg-shaped, 
      thinly white or bluish waxy above, leaf length to width ratio 4:1 | S. pedicillaris | 
  
    | 28 Leaves elliptic, glossy with sunken 
      veins, leaf length to width ratio 3:1 | S. planifolia | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 29 Leaves thin and aromatic when crushed | S. pyrifolia | 
  
    | 29 Leaves not aromatic | 30 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 30 Margins round-toothed or wavy | 31 | 
  
    | 30 Margins saw-toothed, may be glandular | 32 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 31 Branches dark brown to yellowish, 
      becoming hairless; shrubs 2 – 11 m tall | S. discolor | 
  
    | 31 Branches reddish-brown, hairy, 
      may become hairless; shrubs 0.5 – 5 m tall | S. bebbiana | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 32 Leaves hairy below | 33 | 
  
    | 32 Leaves hairless below | 35 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 33 Leaf length to width ratio 6:1 | 34 | 
  
    | 33 Leaf length to width ratio 3:1 | S. planifolia | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 34 Trees to 20 m tall; leaves with 
      appressed white silky hairs above and below | S. alba | 
  
    | 34 Shrubs 1 – 4 m tall; leaves 
      glossy and hairless above, silky hairy below | S. arbusculoides | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 35 Leaf stalks glandular at leaf base | 36 | 
  
    | 35 Leaf stalks glandless at leaf base | 38 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 36 Stipules minute, glandular lobes; 
      flowering in late summer | S. serissima | 
  
    | 36 Stipules leaf-like, semi-oval; 
      flowering in early summer | 37 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 37 Commonly less than 3 m tall, mature 
      leaves abruptly tapered to a tail-like appendage (female catkins to 10 cm, 
      capsules to 7 mm long, on stalks to 2 mm long) | S. lucida ssp. lasiandra | 
  
    | 37 To about 5 m tall, mature leaves 
      caudate abruptly tapered to short tapered (female catkins to 5 cm long, 
      capsules < 7 mm long, on stalks ca. 1 mm long) | S. lucida ssp. lucida | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 38 Stipules persistent, conspicuous, 
      oval | 39 | 
  
    | 38 Stipules deciduous or inconspicuous 
      or linear | 40 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 39 To 7 m tall, branchlets reddish-brown, 
      gray hairy, young leaves green | S. eriocephala var. famelica | 
  
    | 39 To 4 m tall; branchlets yellowish 
      to reddish, hairless to long-hairy, young leaves reddish | S. pseudomonticola | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 40 Leaf tip abruptly tapering to a 
      slender tip | S. amygdaloides  | 
  
    | 40 Leaf tip long to short tapered | 41 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 41 Leaf base tapered | S. petiolaris | 
  
    | 41 Leaf base rounded; Lake Athabasca | 42 | 
  
    |  |  | 
  
    | 42 New leaves white woolly, becoming 
      greyish long-hairy, then hairless; leaves lance-shaped (female catkins on 
      leafy shoots | S. x brachypurpurea | 
  
    | 42 New leaves hairless; leaves lance-shaped 
      to elliptic (female catkins subsessile) | S. turnorii |